Butter + Cream is a top-rated bakery and cake shop in Laguna Niguel, CA, known for crafting fresh, beautifully designed baked goods that make every celebration feel special. From custom cakes and specialty desserts to daily bakery favorites, we bring together quality ingredients, skilled preparation, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps guests coming back.
Whether you are planning a birthday, anniversary, wedding, or simply craving something sweet, Butter + Cream delivers the flavor, presentation, and reliability customers want from a trusted Laguna Niguel bakery and cake shop. With a 4.30-star rating from 60 reviews, we are proud to be a local favorite for memorable treats and exceptional customer experiences.
To discover why Butter + Cream is a preferred bakery and cake shop in Laguna Niguel, CA, visit us for fresh-baked desserts, custom cake options, and delicious creations made to brighten every occasion.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Butter + Cream
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
Wow!!! -Potato Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Cookies! Paul is the the man! Hospitality was dialed! Pizzas had so much flavor it reminded my girl and myself about New York pizza! He’s definitely gotta be from the east coast , because he knows how to make a pizza ! 20/20 recommend ! We will be back for more! Thanks Jesse
Multiple friends recommended this pizza shop and so we went to see what the hype was about, and boy it did not disappoint. Absolutely delicious pizza that puts all the nearby pizza shops to shame. Natalie (the owner) and her team do a fantastic job baking each pie to perfection. Furthermore, I was blow away by the friendly customer service. Each time I’ve gone, I’ve been given a sweet treat to enjoy as I wait for them to bring my order. (The strawberry roll is DEVINE.) I highly recommend the garlic white pizza. Every bite was packed with flavor and the crust was perfectly crispy. Overall, I’ve had an amazing experience here and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for delicious pizza and great service. Give this spot a chance, you won't be disappointed!
Possibly the best pizza in Orange County. On par with truly pizza in my opinion. Cookies are amazing as well, it’s a must try.
As someone who loves to bake, these cookies are phenomenal (this visit I got the chocolate chip and marble). Usually at a lot of places the cookies are too sweet and cakey. These cookies are subtly sweet and have a great texture to them. This is a spot I’d be willing to drive to even though I’m not from the area. Will be coming back!
Butter + Cream made our wedding cake experience so painless! They quoted us a very reasonable amount for our cake, compared to other similar bakeries. The tasting experience was very simple as well, they gave us a box with their different cake flavors and fillings so we could pick and choose our flavor combos. The employee who helped me in person was friendly and easygoing. We picked the cakes up so I can't comment on delivery services. The cake was lovely, moist, flavorful, and I'm so happy with our experience.
Absolutely wonderful food! You can taste the care and love that goes into each dish. I'm not a big cake person, but the cannoli cake was divine! Not too sweet, honestly just right, can't recommend enough : ) The pasta was also incredible, very good blend of flavors.
I tried the new stuffed shell pasta at Butter + Cream and it was delicious. The shells were stuffed to the brim and the sauce was perfectly tangy with fresh basil. I also tried the blueberry dirty soda which was the perfect mix of fizzy and creamy. It's a takeout only spot but I'm glad I stopped by. Definitely trying the pizza next time.
My wife told me she wanted a chocolate raspberry cake for her birthday, I looked around for inspiration and a bakery that could deliver. And I came across this place! Butter+Cream bakery was very helpful in making my wife's cake dream come true! I also spoke with the owner and they were kind enough to create a 'special request' that I made. I'm definitely coming back here for her birthday, our anniversary, and whatever other occasion that gives you an excuse to eat cake!
📍 Butter + Cream These stuffed shells were to die for. Easily a 9/10 😮💨 The owner makes them with a rich red meat sauce and the creamiest, most flavorful cheese stuffing. It honestly reminded me of a stuffed-shell version of my Aunt Martha’s lasagna (and she makes the BEST lasagna), so that’s saying a lot. They’re just phasing pastas onto the menu, and trust me—you don’t want to miss this. I also tried a dirty Sprite for the first time ever and… WOW. 10/10, so refreshing. And the cannoli cake 🤤 came with a mini cannoli on the side—super moist, perfect texture, 10/10. I’m 100% going back to try the pizza 🍕 Go check them out—you’ll thank me later. Also, I want to note that this location is super accessible, with great parking!!
Absolutely loved Butter + Cream in Laguna Niguel. They just launched their new pasta line and everything was so yummy. I also tried their dirty soda, cake, and cannoli — all very tasty treats. They serve pizza too so there’s really something for everyone!
Common questions about Butter + Cream
Butter + Cream is located at 26022 Cape Dr Unit b, Laguna Niguel, CA 92677, United States, Laguna Niguel, CA, United States.
You can reach Butter + Cream by calling +1 949-367-0100.
Butter + Cream has a rating of 4.3 out of 5 based on 60 customer reviews.
Butter + Cream features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Butter + Cream features the following service options: Delivery, Takeaway.
Butter + Cream features the following planning: Quick visit.
Butter + Cream features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Butter + Cream features the following parking: Free parking lot.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
